GoCardless vs PayPal
Considering a switch from PayPal to a European alternative? GoCardless offers full GDPR compliance and EU-only data hosting without the legal uncertainties that come with US-based services. Here's how they compare on features, pricing, and data protection.
Quick Overview
GoCardless
EU- Headquarters
- London, GB
- Pricing
- Per-transaction
- Open Source
- No
PayPal
USPayPal is a global online payment platform that enables individuals and businesses to send and receive money, make purchases, and manage financial transactions digitally.
The Case for GoCardless
- GoCardless stores all data exclusively in GB, EU, under European jurisdiction. Unlike PayPal, which is subject to the US CLOUD Act and FISA Section 702, GoCardless cannot be compelled by foreign governments to hand over your data.
- GoCardless offers a Data Processing Agreement (DPA) that is fully aligned with GDPR Article 28. There is no legal ambiguity about data transfers or adequacy decisions — your data processor is European, and the law that governs it is European.
Why Switch to GoCardless?
Concerns with PayPal
- US CLOUD Act jurisdiction
- Extensive financial data collection and transaction monitoring
- Broad data sharing with partners and third parties
- Account freezing controversies and unilateral enforcement actions
GoCardless Compliance
GDPRDPA
- Headquarters
- London, GB
- Data Centers
- GB, EU
Get Started
Categories
GoCardless vs PayPal — FAQ
Is PayPal GDPR compliant?
PayPal may offer GDPR compliance features and EU data residency options, but as a US-headquartered company, it remains subject to the US CLOUD Act and FISA Section 702. These laws can compel US companies to hand over data regardless of where it is stored. The EU-US Data Privacy Framework provides some safeguards, but its predecessors (Safe Harbor and Privacy Shield) were both invalidated by the European Court of Justice. GoCardless, as a European company, is not subject to these US laws at all.
How does GoCardless compare to PayPal in features?
GoCardless offers Direct Debit (SEPA, Bacs, ACH), Recurring payments, Open banking payments, Payment pages, and 5 more features. While PayPal's ecosystem may be larger due to its market position, GoCardless covers the core functionality that most teams need. The trade-off is typically between breadth of integrations (PayPal) and data sovereignty with regulatory certainty (GoCardless).
Can I migrate from PayPal to GoCardless?
Yes. Most European software providers, including GoCardless, offer migration tools or documentation to help you transition from US-based services. Under GDPR Article 20, you have the right to data portability — meaning PayPal must provide your data in a machine-readable format. The migration process varies in complexity depending on your data volume and integrations, but for most teams it can be completed within a few days to a few weeks.